Judge Rules Gutierrez’s Appointment Violated District Boundary Laws by Breeanna Jent - City News Group, Inc.
View Upcoming Events View Your Local Sales

Community Calendar

◄ NOVEMBER ►
S M T W T F S
01 02 03 04 05 06 07
08 09 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 01 02 03 04 05
View Events
Submit Events
directory

Judge Rules Gutierrez’s Appointment Violated District Boundary Laws

By Breeanna Jent, Staff Writer
August 4, 2014 at 11:45am. Views: 83

Moreno Valley’s District 4 Councilman, Yxstian Gutierrez, must leave office by Aug. 5 as ordered by a judge who stood by his tentative ruling July 29 that the councilman was not legally appointed to the seat. Judge Craig Riemer of the Riverside County Superior Court ruled in favor of three District 4 residents who sued Gutierrez on the grounds that he did not reside within the lawful boundaries of District 4 during the time of his appointment and that his appointment in September 2013 by the City Council violated the Brown Act. A statement issued Tuesday, July 29 by Gutierrez said he would be seeking an appeal to the decision. “While I am disappointed in today’s ruling… I have faith in our judicial system to review the case in its entirety,” the statement read. Gutierrez was appointed by the city council during a September 2013 council meeting to represent District 4 after the seat was left vacated by former councilman Marcelo Co, who last August was arrested for accepting a record $2.36 million bribe, to which he plead guilty. The judge held Gutierrez did not reside in District 4 boundaries at the time of his appointment. No mention was made in the ruling of whether Gutierrez’s appointment to the dais—he was sworn in immediately after his appointment—was done as a result of secret meetings between a majority of the council, violating the Brown Act, as several lawyers and Moreno Valley residents, including the plaintiffs in this case, Basil Kimbrew, Radene Ramos Hiers and Deanna Reeder, alleged. Court documents explained that alleged violation of the Brown Act involved “disputed factual issues” and was “therefore not a basis for the instant motion.” The argument rested upon definition of District 4 boundaries. At the time Co was elected in November 2010, Gutierrez’s home was not part of the council district, but after redistricting was done to reflect updated census figures in October 2011, Gutierrez’s home became part of District 4. Judge Riemer sided with the state attorney general in his tentative ruling, saying that the 2010 boundaries remain in effect through the remainder of Co’s term. Riemer used a similar 1942 California Supreme Court Case, Sloan v. Donahue, involving a vacant congressional district seat to make his judgment. Gutierrez and his Los Angeles-based attorneys, Thomas Long and Amber Maltbie, argued that the new boundaries should apply, in order to keep other residents from remaining unrepresented by their council until the November election. “My attorneys and I believe the court misinterpreted the law,” Gutierrez said in a written statement. “Thousands of residents of my neighborhood…were removed from District 3 and not allowed to vote in the November 2012 election, nor the 2010 city council election.” Gutierrez said this “limbo” was “unnecessary and disrespectful to the constitutional rights” of citizens. “It’s public record…Gutierrez has a very poor voting record,” Hiers told the Moreno Valley City News. “It’s ironic that he is fighting for the people’s right to vote when he doesn’t respect his right to vote.” Gutierrez is seeking an appeal for the decision. Hiers said she doesn’t think Gutierrez’s appeal will be granted. “I find it highly unlikely that he will stay after August 5,” she said. Candidate logs show Gutierrez has filed to run for the District 4 seat in the November election.

Related Articles

Photo Courtesy of: TME Photography by Titan Mom Elvira

By Titan Mom Elvira, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:26pm. Views: 188

Athlete of the Week Christopher Michael Lemos, Redlands High School Junior and Varsity Quarterback, proudly represents the Terriers with his dedication, leadership, and passion for the game.

Photo Courtesy of: City News Group

By Ruby Stephenson, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:26pm. Views: 184

Redlands Pottery Project joins A.K. Smiley Public Library for a November 14 workshop designed for young artists ages 13 to 18. A lump of clay may not look like much at first. In the hands of a young artist, however, it can become a bowl, a decorative sculpture or an entirely unexpected creation.

Photo Courtesy of: https://www.redlands.edu/

By William Cortez, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:26pm. Views: 174

The University of Redlands Department of Theatre and Dance will present Día de los Muertos and Other Folk Tales November 5 through 8, 2026. Stories told by grandparents often become treasured parts of a family's history. Some are humorous, others mysterious, and many carry lessons that remain meaningful long after the storyteller is gone.

Photo Courtesy of: UC San Diego's ALERTCalifornia

By Ruby Stephenson, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:26pm. Views: 191

A remote wildfire-monitoring camera overlooks a Southern California landscape. Redlands has partnered with UC San Diego's ALERTCalifornia program to improve monitoring of areas near northern Redlands and the Santa Ana River wash.

Photo Courtesy of: https://www.akspl.org/events/

By William Cortez, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:26pm. Views: 181

Annual ceremony at the Lincoln Memorial Shrine will bring American history to life on November 21. On a November morning in Redlands, the sounds of fifes, drums and historic artillery will offer residents an opportunity to experience a chapter of American history that continues to influence the nation more than 160 years after the Civil War.

Photo Courtesy of: City News Group

By Stella Pierce, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:18pm. Views: 196

The first years of a child's life are filled with milestones that families often remember forever. A baby's first smile, the first attempt to crawl and the first spoken words are moments of celebration. They can also bring questions, uncertainty and new responsibilities for parents learning how to care for a growing child.

Photo Courtesy of: https://www.csusb.edu/

By Ruby Stephenson, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:06pm. Views: 186

CSUSB’s Department of Physics and Astronomy has earned recognition for it for its work to create a more inclusive, diverse and supportive physics department, earning the Bronze Award from the American Association for the Advancement of Science Physics & Astronomy SEA Change program.

Photo Courtesy of: https://www.naco.org/program/operation-green-light-veterans

By William Cortez, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:06pm. Views: 182

Operation Green Light returns November 4–11, encouraging residents to recognize military service and help veterans connect with available resources. As darkness settles over San Bernardino during the first week of November, green lights will illuminate several county buildings, transforming familiar government facilities into visible reminders of the sacrifices made by America's military veterans.

Photo Courtesy of: https://www.authentikusa.com/

By Amanda Spencer, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:06pm. Views: 186

As America's most famous highway celebrates its centennial in 2026, San Bernardino reflects on the road that helped shape its neighborhoods, businesses and identity. Long before interstate highways became the preferred routes for cross-country travel, motorists making their way through San Bernardino followed a road that would become one of the most recognizable highways in American history.

Photo Courtesy of: Corina Borsuk and provided courtesy of SBCUSD

By Amanda Spencer, Community Writer

November 3, 2026 at 03:06pm. Views: 154

Muscoy Elementary students join SBCUSD Superintendent Mauricio Arellano, Board of Education President Mayra Ceballos, Assistant Superintendents Dr. Sandra Rodriguez and Dr. Tasha Doizan, Director MaryRone Goodwin and San Bernardino County Supervisor Joe Baca Jr. for the official ribbon cutting ceremony that opened the school’s new outdoor learning center.

Photo Courtesy of: https://riversiderecord.org/; A photo of Moreno Valley City Hall. (Alicia Ramirez/The Riverside Record) Credit: (Photo by Alicia

By Ruby Stephenson, Community Writer

October 27, 2026 at 02:39pm. Views: 567

A city is often judged by what residents experience every day: the condition of its streets, the reliability of public services, the availability of recreational programs and the ease of obtaining information from local government. Behind those everyday experiences are departments and employees whose work rarely attracts national attention.

Photo Courtesy of: TME Photography by Titan Mom Elvira

By Titan Mom Elvira, Community Writer

October 27, 2026 at 02:39pm. Views: 535

Athlete of the Week Zachary Scott Perez, Senior at John W. North High School, is recognized as Athlete of the Week for his dedication and accomplishments as a student athlete.

--> -->